"Do you believe?" In the wake of her divorce, Amanda Donovan desires to leave the painful memories of her shattered marriage behind in Boston and spend Valentine's Day hidden within the seclusion and beauty of Marblehead Light. She rents the isolated lightkeeper's cottage for a week but as visions of a strikingly handsome man begin to haunt her, she begins to realize there is no escaping the past. Even if it is not her own.